|
Who are We?
What do we do?
Latest News
Free Resources
Links
|
|
|
DATING THE KURUKSHETRA
WAR
|
Scholars from across the world came together, for the first
time, in an attempt to establish the 'Date of Kurukshetra War
based on astronomical data.' Undoubtedly, it was an amazing
collation of information presented in a colloquium, held on
January 5 and 6, 2003 at the Mythic Society, Bangalore. The
colloquium was jointly organized by The Mythic Society, Indira
Gandhi National Centre for the Arts - Southern Regional Centre
and Sir Babasaheb (Umakanth Keshav) Apte Smarak Samithi Trust.
Inaugurating the two day session, Dr. Raja Ramanna, Member of
Parliament and eminent nuclear scientist, emphasized that the
'best clock for dating was the sky itself and the position of
stars.' He added that 'research and scientific theory should be
questioned although he found that many homes and libraries
hampered the progress of research by keeping ancient manuscripts
to themselves.'
Dr.
Kalyana Raman clarified the purpose of the colloquium in his
introductory remarks. Well-known historian, Dr. Suryanath
Kamath, in his Presidential address explained the objective as
an ' exploration of the authenticity of dates using planetary
software and textual evidences containing over 150 references.'
He felt that 'chronology was most important for the history of
any society since history without chronology is like a body
without a skeleton.' He also gave a detailed explanation of the
development of the Mythic library and the collections.
The
other dignitaries present on the dais were Dr. M.K.L.N. Sastry -
Hon. Secretary, Mythic Society, Prof. P.V. Krishna Bhat - Hon.
Coordinator, IGNCA-SRC and Shri K. Narahari - Managing Trustee,
Apte Trust. The opening session set the tone for the mind
stirring sessions with various interpolations found in the
Mahabharata. Several scholars put forth their perception
and calculated derivations. Dr. S. Balakrishna (NASA, USA)
proved the occurrence of 'two eclipses in (a span of)
13 days prior to Mahabharata'. Analysing the astronomical
possibility of Vyasa's statement in Bhishma Parva "Amavasya
occured on the 13th day. Two eclipses in a month, on the
thirteenth day." he presented the data of eclipses during the
period 3300 BCJ (Before the Calendar of Julian Ceaser) to 700
BCJ visible at Kuruxethra, using Lodestar Pro software. He
stated the possibility of 672 eclipse pairs, ten 'thirteen day
lunar first' eclipse pairs and concluded that 2559 BC eclipse
pair was nearest to the text of Mahabharata.
Prof. R.N. Iyengar (I.I.Sc., Bangalore) systematically dealt
with "Internal consistency of eclipses and planetary
positions in Mahabharata". Verifying all double eclipses of
501-3000 B.C. and when Satur + Jupiter were near Vishaka,
he concluded that 1478 B.C. was the most likely year of the war.
Dr.
B.N. Narahari Achar (Dept. of Physics, University of Memphis,
U.S.A.) gave a brief description of various available planetary
software, a review of the works of astrophysicists Kochhar,
Siddharth and astronomers, Sengupta and Srinivasa Raghavan and
other astronomical references in the epic. He critically
examined the limitations and the reliability of simulations and
concluded that the astronomical events in the Mahabharata
pointed to 3000 B.C.E. (Before Common Era)* and simulation of
events to 3067 B.C.E., identical to the one given by Raghavan.
Speaking on 'The date of Mahabharata War with reference to
Bhishmashtami', Dr. Kalyan Rama (Chennai) validated the
ground truth of River Saraswati of Vedic times that established
the historicity of the Mahabharata.
Dr.
Shambhu Shastry (Franklin, USA) and Dr. Venkateswara Reddy dealt
with 'Natural cycles in the Solar System and Chaturyuga
Cycles.' Dr. Kalyan Raman (Chennai) validated the ground
truth of River Saraswati of Vedic times that established the
historicity of the Mahabharata.
Dr.
Shambu Shastry (Franklin, USA) and Dr. Venkateswara Reddy dealt
with 'Natural cycles in the Solar System and Chaturyuga
Cycles.' Dr. Shambhu Shastry showed that the chatuyuga
and manavantara schemes of Hindu chronology are
directly from natural astronomical cycles and based on this, he
stated, that the human race is about five million years old. He
concluded that this helped demythologize the Mahabharata
and Ramayana and placed them in the last descending
Chaturyuga segment over a time span of not more than 6000
years.
Shri
P.V. Holey (Nagpur) was of the opinion that the war began on the
13th day of November 3143 B.C. He sourced this to crucial
events with planetary positions after a comparative study of
astronomical dates based on nakshatra, the Julian and
Gregorian systems.
On
the second day, Dr. Mohan Gupta (Ujjain) dealt with Puranic
and Astronomical evidences. Based on genealogical and
astronomical calculations he concluded that 17th October 1952
B.C. Thursday, Marga Krsna Amavasya kali 1157 or
shakapurva 2029, Julian year 2762 as the date when the
Mahabharata war began. Dr. S.R. Rao based his derivation on
archaeological evidence obtained from onshore and offshore
excavations conducted in Dwaraka, Bet Dwarka and in the
Kurukshetra region and found 1900-1700 B.C. as acceptable.
Dr.
N.S. Rajaram (Bangalore) expressed a need to exercise caution
while interpreting astronomicla statements and that it should
take into account both the literary evolution and interpolated
passages. He felt 3100m B.C. had the best astronomical
support. Shri K.V. Ramakrishna Rao (Thiruvananthapuram), felt
that due to periodical corrections in Indian astronomical works,
changes had crept it and without the significance of the two
ears - kali and saka - dates cannot be determined,
Dr. M.V. Subba Rao (Secundrabad) gave astrological references of
Sri Krishna and felt that the dates could be calcutated from the
day of Ktrishna's birth. Shri M.V. Narasimhan (Mysore) spoke of
a research methodology using the shastric and the
scientific inputs. Referring to Pulakesin's inscription and
comet at Nagercoil he concluded 3100 B.C. as the year of the
war.
Despite the inspiring deliberations, it was observed that
further resource data from varied fields was required to
calibrate supportive evidence. Thus the concluding session
unanimously drew a plan of action. Dr. S. Nagaraju reviewed the
colloquium with regard to the two objectives set at the
beginning - to establish internal consistency with respect to
dates and chronology mentioned in the Mahabharata and
whether it could be proved using planetary software and
secondly, if a correct date of the Mahabharata could be
derived from the 150 astronomical references and have a sheet
anchor of chronology of pre-Buddhist India? He said that at
least four papers dealt with the problem directly and clarified
a non-discrepancy with respect to the dates given. This is he
felt was the most important contribution of the colloquium. But
a problem he sighted was, out of the one-lakh odd sholkas,
to distinguish what was added at what time. In this context he
suggested that more interactions might be had with people who
had knowledge of geography and other related areas of study.
Secondly, he felt that the dating of the Mahabharata war
could not be done merely on the basis of astronomy alone. Since
there are a number of texts one should find out the correct text
and establish a critical edition giving all details.
Dr.
R. Subramaniam in his observations also agreed that there was a
need to develop a critical editions of the verses with
interpretations in consensus with astronomy, history,
archaeology, Sanskrit astrology and mathematics. He suggested
that verifications should take into account occurrence of double
eclipse, Saturn in Rohini and the use of all available software
and data. Another valid point he raised was the absence of
direct reference to winter solstice in the Mahabharata.
Once that is available it was felt that 'everything could be
nailed.'
'Where do we go from here?' Answering the self-query Dr. Kalyan
Raman voiced the common desire to 'trash Western Indological
work done with motivation and instead rewrite Indian history.'
The fundamental task would bring to light traditional works
which can be achieved in a series of colloquiums. Truth, he
felt, should be perceived in terms of our national heritage and
his colloquium had established the reliability of this tool.
The
Chairperson, Prof. K.I. Vasu addressed the various issues
discussed and surmized that the Mahabharata could be
'considered a historical document'.
-
Report from Southern Regional Centre
* (B.C.E.
- Before Common Era (indicates dates before the Chiristian era,
used especially by non-Christians; B.C.J. - indicated the Julian
Calendar. The Julian Calendar is names after Julius Caesar who
ordered its adoption in 45 B.C.E. upon the advice of Greek
astronomer Sosigenes and decided to use a purely solar
calendar. The Julian Calendar also established the order of the
month and the days of the week as they exist in present day
calendars. Caesar's Calendar consisted of 11 months of 30 or 31
days and a 28 day February with no leap year. In 1582 Pope
Gregory XIII ordered another reform of the calendar, which came
to be known as the Gregorian calendar. The Gregorian calendar
is still in official use and was adopted throughout Europe. It
is used today throughout most of the Western world and in parts
of Asia.)
Copyright IGNCAŠ 2001
Mahabharata as the sheet-anchor of Bharatiya Itihaasa
S Kalyanaraman
(This is a mirror site of
the above)
The
following pages describe some details of the path-breaking
colloquium held in Bangalore on 5th and 6th January 2003:
Historicity
of Mahabharata (An analysis of Dr. BN Narahari Achar's
presentation by Dr. S. Kalyanaraman)
Mahabharata
Planetarium Project
Overview of the International Colloquium (together with links to
papers presented)
The
following key dates are found to be consistent with the sky
inscriptions observed by Veda Vyasa:
-
Krishna's departure on Revati Sept. 26, 3067 BCE
-
Krishna's arrival in Hastinapura on Bharani Sept. 28, 3067
BCE
-
Solar
eclipse on Jyeshtha amavasya Oct. 14, 3067 BCE
-
Krittika
full moon (lunar eclipse) September 29, 3067 BCE
-
War
starts on November 22, 3067 BCE (Saturn in Rohini, Jupiter
in Revati)
-
Winter
solstice, January 13, 3066 BCE
-
Bhishma's expiry, January 17, 3066 BCE Magha shukla ashtami
-
A fierce
comet at Pushya October 3067 BCE
-
Balarama
sets off on pilgrimage on Sarasvati on Pushya day Nov. 1,
3067 BCE
-
Balarama
returns from pilgrimage on Sravana day Dec. 12, 3067 BCE
-
On the
day Ghatotkaca was killed moon rose at 2 a.m., Dec. 8, 3067
BCE
These
dates, in particular the occurrence of Winter solstice which is
a critical celestial event, gets corroborated by the chronology
of Kaus'i_taki Brahmana which should not be far-removed
from the date of S'atapatha Brahman.a which has been
established by Dr. BN Narahari Achar based on the Brahmana
observations that the Kritthika (Pleiades group) rose exactly at
the east point (eta_ ha vai pra_cyai dis'e na cyavante: S'Br. II
Kanda, Ch. 1, Br. 2,3).
In
Kaus'i_taki Brahmana there are two statements:
sa vai ma_ghasya_ma_vasya_ya_mupas'asatyadangabha_vai
sannupeme (KBr. XIX,3)
mukham
va_ etat samvatr.sarasva yatr. pha_lguni_ paurn.ama_si_
mukhamuttare puccham pu_rve
(KBr., V,1)
[cf. S'Br.
VI.2.2.18; Taittiriya Br. 1.1.2.8].
These
observations indicate that
- the sun reached the winter
solstice at the full moon Ma_gha
- the year was considered to
be at its end at the full-moon at the star group Purva
Phalguni_.
Dr. Phanindralal Gangooly notes:
"From all of which we gather that the summer solstitial colure
of the earliest Brahmana period when this was the case was 3100
BCE (PC Sengupta, Age of the Brahmana, in Indian Historical
Quarterly, Vol. X, No.3, 1934). The vernal equinoctial
colure passed through the star Rohini or Aldebaran. In the later
Vedic times the sun's turning north very probably took place a
fortnight earlier. The S'atapatha Brahmana says that 'some want
to have a few nights more; if they want some more then they
should begin the sacrifices on the night on which the moon
becomes first visible before the full moon at the Phalgunis.' (S'Br.
II,6.4 Br. 11). These sacrifices were begun as soon as the sun
turned north. It shows that the solstices had preced by about 15
degrees and that the date when this took place was 2000 BCE. The
earliest Brahmana period may be called the Rohini-Phalguni_
period. Even at this time the five early luni-solar cycle was
known. (pancas'a_radauyo va_ eva yajn~a iti: TBr. 2.7.11). The
calendar was luni-solar in characte. The chief signals for the
beginning and the end of the year were the full-moon at the U.
Phalguni_ and that at the Purva Phalguni_ respectively; from
which the intercalary month were detected." (Phanindralal
Gangolly, ed., The Surya SIddhanta, a text-book of Hindu
Astronomy, Delhi, Motilal Banarsidass, first edn. 1860, repr.
Delhi 1989, Introduction, pp. xxxv-xxxvi).
S. Kalyanaraman
8 January 2003
Historicity of Mahabharata; Discovery and Rebirth of
River Sarasvati
Sarasvati is ground-truth. So is Mahabharata an account of
the ancient history of Bharat. The dating of this epic is
fundamental in establishing the historical chronology of ancient
Bharatiya Itihaas.
Veda Vyasa who wrote the Mahabharata observed the sky
inscriptions from the banks of River Sarasvati. The epic
describes a pilgrimage of Balarama (elder brother of Krishna)
from Dwaraka-Somnath(Prabhas Patan) to Mathura along the banks
of River Sarasvati in 200 shlokas in the S'alya Parvan.
This date of Mahabharata War is crucial in determing the
chronologies in the ancient history of Bharat since many
epigraphs and inscriptions with a historical import, refer to
time-reckoning based on the starting date of Kaliyuga which is
close to the date of the Mahabharata War.
Dating Mahabharata events using astronomical references
Using a set of modern technology tools such as Planetarium
Software (Sky Map Pro 5, Red Shift), Panchanga Software compiled
by a Japanese professor to produce the equivalence between
Kaliyuga dates and dates of the Christian era, Dr. Narahari
Achar has tried to authenticate the accuracy of observations
made by Veda Vyasa in the Mahabharata.
In the epic, Veda Vyasa himself says that day in and day out
he is watching the planetary positions on the skies. His
recording of over 70 such planetary events are almost like a
record of celestial inscriptions within the text. These
celestial events are used to date the events which occurred on
the banks of River Sarasvati -- events which are described in
the epic poem. Since the planets on the sky and the celestial
events are remarkably accurate and follow a precise pattern of
cyclical movements, to a rhythm of time, the determination of
planetary positions as observed by Veda Vyasa will help
determine the date of events described in detail in the shlokas
of Mahabharata.
In the past, many scholars have attempted to arrive at the
date of the war based on one or two celestial events mentioned
in the text. But, the contribution made by Dr. Narahari Achar is
unique in that he tries to find a series of dates which is
consistent with almost ALL the 150 plus astronomical references
contained in the text.
Akhila Bharateeya Itihaasa Sankalana Yojana has published a
reference work by Shriram Sathe as a compendium of astronomical
references in the Mahabharata. This work has provided the
basis for this International Colloquium.
In a paper presented at the international colloquium held in
Bangalore on Jan. 5 and 6, 2003 and organized by Akhila
Bharatiya Itihasa Sankalana Yojana, Mythic Society and Indira
Gandhi National Centre for Arts Southern Chapter, Dr. Achar
conclusively proves that the observed celestial events on the
sky, observed by Veda Vyasa were based on a variety of
observations:
1. Lunar-solar-lunar eclipse sequence occurring within a
period of one month and one lunar-solar eclipse sequence
occurring within just 13 tithi-s;
2. A comet (Haley's comet) is observed on the sky;
3. Bhishma waits for the uttarayana punya kaala (winter
solstice) and ashtami tithi to arrive before
his soul departs from the mortal body;
4. Karna describes to Krishna the observatin of unusual
planetary conjunctions -- almost all the seven planets
coming together;
5. Balarama's pilgrimage starts on a particular tithi and
nakshatra and ends after 42 days on a particular tithi and
nakshatra. All such observations are found by Dr. Narahari
Achar to be consistent with only one date: about 3000 BCE,
i.e. about 5000 years ago. No other date matches so
consistenly with all the astronomical observations or, what
may be called, celestial inscriptions.
This finding is historic and constitutes a watershed in our
understanding of chronology in ancient itihasa of Bharat.
Firstly, it establishes the historic authenticity of
Mahabharata as a sheet anchor of Bharatiya Itihas.
Secondly, Veda Vyasa should have recorded only observed
celestial events when he provides precise astronomical details
in the text. The observations should have been made from the
banks of River Sarasvati close to Kurukshetra. Dr. Narahari
Achar reconstructs the skies as seen by Veda Vyasa from this
location close to Kurukshetra.
Thirdly, together with the scientific discovery of the River
Sarasvati in north-west Bharat as ground-truth and not a myth,
it is possible to state with authenticity that the modern
history of Bharat begins with the historic document, the
Mahabharata and the War which occurred on the banks of River
Sarasvati.
Fourthly, Balarama's pilgrimage along the banks of River
Sarasvati as described in 200 shlokas of Salya Parva of the
Mahabharata was a historic event and provides a geographical
account of northern Bharat.
Fifthly, the history of modern Bharat begins from about 3000
BCE, that is, from the Kaliyuga which is reckoned from this
date, according to Bharatiya Kala Ganana.
Sixthly, there is no historic document in human history which
records historical events with such astonishing accuracy, to the
last tithi and nakshatra.
Seventhly, this demonstrates the remarkable astronomical
knowledge possessed by the rishis of Bharata, exemplified by
Veda Vyasa as early as 5000 years ago and establishes Jyotisha
which was evolved in Bharata, as an early astronomical
scientific discipline.
Thus, using modern astronomy computer-based software tools,
it is now possible to state that Mahabharata of Veda Vyasa is
the earliest recorded history of Bharat and the modern history
spans from over 5000 years of continuous, indigenous
civilization. The chronology of Bharatiya Itihas should be
reconstructed from this date and based on this historical
document, and need not be based on foreign travellers' accounts
or theories propounded by western indologists.
Next steps.
It is proposed to transport this presentation onto Planetaria
in many cities of the country and abroad; the presentation
will show Veda Vyasa's text juxtaposed to the celestial
inscriptions. This will be an effective means of popularising
jyotisha and itihas, i.e. by reaching the research findings in
Bharatiya Itihas to a large number of school children and
scholars all over the world and promoting further studies in
Mahabharata as a sheet-anchor of Bharatiya Itihas. Hopefully,
the findings will also be recorded on CD's and distributed to
all schools as part of the value-based revised curricula.
Brief introduction of Dr. S. Kalyanaraman and his
lecture-Power-point presentation:
The rebirth of River Sarasvati by using the waters of River
Sutlej, River Beas and River Sharada (called Mahakali-Karnali in
Nepal) is ongoing together with the development of the river
basin as a world heritage basin. This has been the catalyst for
the project to network Himalayan and Peninsular rivers of the
country to solve the twin problems of frequent floods in some
parts of the country and recurrent drought situations in other
parts of the country. The work of the National Water Development
Agency, Min. of Water Resources with 200 engineers who have
worked for the last 20 years to prove the feasibility of these
links almost entirely by gravity flows is a magnificent
engineering project linking Brahmaputra- Ganga- Subarnarekha-
Mahanadi-Godavari-Krishna-Pennar-Palar-Cauvery-Vaigai-Vaippar-Gundar-Tamraparni
to ensure equitable distribution of water resources in the
country mainly fed from the glacier sources.
The civilization which was nurtured on the banks of the river
constituted the substratum of the Sarasvati-Sindhu (earlier
called Indus Valley) Civilization dated to between circa 5500 to
3500 years Before Present. With the desiccation of the river,
there were migrations eastward towards the Ganga-Yamuna doab,
southwards towards the Godavari and western coastline, westwards
towards Gandhara in the present-day Afghanistan. The neolithic
cultures which are evidenced by the recent finds of the Gulf of
Khambat Cultural Complex blossomed from a maritime culture into
a riverine culture and emerged from chalcolithic to bronze age
and the consolidation of the cultural traditions which are
present in almost every facet of the heritage cherished all over
Bharat and exemplify the cultural unity of the country from Mt.
Kailas to Kanyakumari, from Somnath to Gawuhati. The
civilization was most extensive and extended from Ropar in
Punjab to the Tigris-Euphrates valley (Mesopotamian civilization
area), from Caucus mountains to Daimabad on the banks of
Godavari.
The discovery of the courses of Vedic River Sarasvati
traversing a distance of 1,600 kms. from Manasarovar (Mt. Kailas)
to Gujarat is an unparalleled discovery in the history of human
civilization. Carrying the waters of River Sutlej and River
Yamuna, the mighty river had drained most of North-west Bharat
for thousands of years prior to 3500 year Before Present (i.e.
prior to 1500 BCE). The causes for the desiccation of the river
have been established: tectonic events of the type which hit
Bhuj in Gujarat on 26 Jan. 2000 which are plate tectonics (clash
of Deccan Plate with the Eurasian Plate) resulted in river
migrations and disappearance of the river into underground
channels in many stretches. River Yamuna migrated eastward circa
4500 years Before Present (i.e. 2500 BCE) and River Sutlej
migrated westward circa 3500 years Before Present (i.e. 1500
BCE) leaving the River Sarasvati entirely dependent upon monsoon
waters of the Siwalik ranges, depriving her of the glacier
waters of the Himalayas. River Yamuna captured the waters of
River Sarasvati at Paonta Saheb (Himachal Pradesh), near a
yamuna tear in the Himalayas, and carried them to join with
Ganga at Prayag (Allahabad) thus establishing the ground-truth
of what is referred to in Bharatiya tradition as Triveni
Sangamam where a kumbhamela is held every 12 years. The
discovery of the ancient channels which were as wide as 6 kms.
over the entire distance has been substantiated by analyses of
satellite imagery and by studies done by atomic scientists of
Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, Mumbai (tritium analysis). The
tritium analysis was done in the wake of the Pokaran
hydrogen-bomb blasts which occurred on 11 May 1998 to ensure
that there has been no nuclear contamination of the ground-water
aquifers. The most emphatic evidence that Sarasvati is not a
myth but ground-truth came from archaeology of the last 50
years. Out of over 2,600 archaeological sites of the so-called
Indus Valley Civilization, as many as 2,000 (i.e 80%) of the
site are found on the banks of the River Sarasvati which flowed
300 kms. east of the River Sindhu. There are very large sites on
this River banks: Rakhigarhi, Lakhmirwala, Bhatinda, Ganweriwala,
each of which is larger than either Harappa or Mohenjodaro.
There are also culturally vibrant sites such as Ropar, Kunal,
Kalibangan, Kotdiji, Dholavira, Surkotada, Lothal, Rangapura,
Rojdi, Padri, Dwaraka attesting to the maritime-riverine nature
of the indigenous origins and evolution of the civilization. The
cultural traits found in this civilization continue into the
historic periods of Bharat and are present even today in the
cultural mosaic of the nation. Some examples are: finds of shiva
linga at Harappa (dated to 4,500 years BP), finds of 50 seals
and copper plate inscriptions carrying the swastika glyph, find
of a burial site of a woman at Mehergarh dated to 6500 BCE (i.e.
8500 BP) with a wide bangle and ornaments made of s'ankha (turbinella
pyrum); this s'ankha is a Rs.5 crore industry even today in the
coastline of Bharat particularly in Gulf of Mannar and Gulf of
Khambat; find of a terracotta image of a woman wearing red
sindhu on the parting of her hair; find of a statuette of a
priest wearing angavastram as it is worn even today by priests
in Bharat; find of polished stone pillars at Dholavira like the
stone pillars found in many architectural monuments all over
Bharat; find of a rock-cut reservoir and a pushkarini at
Dholavira and Mohenjodaro, like the pushkara-s which are present
in many tirthasthana-s of the country; find of boat and cart
similar to those used even today in the region. The use of
copper plate inscriptions continued into the historicla periods
within the country. Such is the uniqueness of the River
Sarasvati that there are 72 r.ca-s in the R.gveda adoring the
river; one Rishi Grtsamada calls her ambitame, naditame,
devitame sarasvati: i.e. best of mothers, best of rivers and
best of godesses. There is only one reference to River Ganga in
this document attesting to the fact that the oldest human
document, the R.gveda was composed on the banks of the River
Sarasvati. The vedic dharma and vrata traditions and the agama
traditions which have their roots in the river basin, continue
in the cultural mosaic of the nation.
Such a great river got desiccated which led to migrations of
people eastwards towards the ganga-yamuna doab, westwards
towards Gandhara, southwards hugging the coastline. Thus, it is
conclusively established that the roots of bharatiya
civilization were indigenously evolved and there were only
contacts with neighbouring civilizations such as Mesopotamia and
Caucasus for trade. This is attested by the finds of decimal
series of weights used in the civilization also used in the
Persian Gulf sites. A cuneiform cylinder seal found in
Mesopotamia depicts a Meluhha merchant visiting a royal
personage in Mesopotamia accompanied by his wife carrying a
kamandalu. It is generally accepted that Meluhha referred to the
Sarasvati-Riverine-Maritime civilization area.
The projects for reviving this river using check-dams and
watershed management techniques to harvest the monsoon waters of
Shivalik ranges, have started to ensure the availability of
water in River Sarasvati from Adh Badri to Sirsa all the year
round. With the dams on Sutlej (Bhakra and Nangal) and on Beas
(Pong) providing the waters at the Harike reservoir, a Rajasthan
Canal (also called Sarasvati Mahanadi Roopa Nahar) has
transformed the desert areas into fertile lands over a stretch
of 650 kms. Projects are ongoing to extend the Sarasvati Canal
beyond Gedra Road (Barmer Dist.) upto Rann of Kutch. By
augmenting this canal with the glacier waters of
Mahakali-Karnali (Nepal) - Sharada (Bharat) which will be
transferred across Yamuna, the Reborn Sarasvati will flow upto
River Sabarmati.
S. Kalyanaraman
8 January 2003
Dr. B.N. Narahari Achar is a Professor in the Department of
Physics, University of Memphis, USA. He obtained his Ph.D.in
1968 from Pennsylvania State University. His researches are in
Theoretical solid state physics and in ancient tradition of
Vedanga Jyotisha. He has published a number of papers in
academic and scientific journals on the use of modern
astronomical techniques for validating the astronomical
references contained in the ancient texts of Bharat. He has
reviewed over 150 years of scholarly works related to dating
Mahabharata with particular reference to over 70 astronomical
references contained in the Mahabharata itself. He has found a
way to simulate the planetary positions on the skies and
to validate the accuracy or otherwise of conflicting dates
arrived at by scholars for the date of the Mahabharata War.
Dr. S. Kalyanaraman was a Senior Executive in the Asian
Development Bank between 1978 and 1995 responsible for a
disbursement portfolio of US Dollars 60 billion and
world-wide information systems network of the Bank. Earlier he
was a member of the Indian Railway Accounts Service and Chief
Controller of Accounts, Karnataka Electricity Board.
He has compiled a multi-lingual comparative dictionary of 25
ancient Indian languages. He has set up a web-site on River
Sarasvati and Civilization at http://www.hindunet.org/saraswati
with over 30,000 files.
His presentation focussed on River Sarasvati, Civilization,
Rebirth of River Sarasvati and National River Network Project.
The discovery of Vedic River Sarasvati is a historic event
unparalleled in the history of human civilization. The river is
not a myth but is ground-truth and had drained in North-west
Bharat over a distance of 1,600 kms. from Manasarovar, Mt.
Kailas to Gujarat (Somnath, Prabhas Patan). The discovery has
been made through analyses of satellite images, archaeological
discoveries of over 2,000 archaeological sites on the banks of
the river, tritium analysis by atomic scientists and
geomorphological/glaciological studies. The causes for the
desiccation of this great river has also been established as due
to plate tectonics and consequent river migrations over a period
of 1000 years between 4500 to 3500 years Before Present.
Projects have been started to make this river flow again. The
river nurtured the civilization of Bharat on its banks and in
the coastal areas surrounding Gujarat with emphatic evidences of
indigenous evolution and continuity of culture in the historic
periods of Bharat thus constituting the roots of Bharatiya
Civilization
MAHABHARATA
PLANETARIUM PROJECT
Objective
The objective is to demonstrate that over 70
sky inscriptions mentioned by Veda Vya_sa in the Mahabha_rata
are remarkably scientific dates of the War. This demonstration
will be presented in Planetaria all over the world simulating
the skies as seen from Kurukshetra by Veda Vya_sa using
astronomical computational software. This will validate the
Maha_bha_rata as a historical document, a sheet-anchor of
the modern history of Bharat which commences in 3012 BCE (Before
Common Era, according to the Gregorian Calendar).
Background
From 22nd to 24th
November, 2002 a national seminar was organized on History of
India through Vedic Astronomy under the patronage of Dr. N.
Mahalingam. On 5 and 6 January 2003, a colloquium will be held
in Bangalore under the auspices of the Yojana, the Mythic
Society and Indira Gandhi National Centre for Arts Southern
Regional Chapter on Date of Mahabharata using only
astronomical references. Dr. Narahari Achar will be
presenting his findings together with scientists and scholars.
Dr. Ramasubramanian, Professor of
Theortetical Physics in University of Madras made a brilliant
presentation on the purpose, and methodology of Indian
Astronomy.
I mentioned in the seminar about the
path-breaking work done by Dr. Narahari Achar of Universit of
Memphis, USA, validating, (using Planetarium Software, Sky Pro
and Red Shift Sky computer software), Prof. Srinivasa Raghavans
computations (using Vedanga Jyotisha, in 1979) on the
astronomical references mentioned in the Mahabharata.
Dr. Sabaratnam and Shri V. Sundaram also
associated with Dr. Mahalingam had arranged for a visit to the
planetarium in Chennai. The director of the Birla planaterium,
Dr. Ayyan Perumal mentioned during their presentation of the
Haleys Comets history that the planetarium has software which
can reconstruct the inscriptions on the skies upto 26,000 years
Before Present.
The proposed project
Now, the idea is this. We will organize a
team of young scholars to work with the Birla Planetarium, under
the guidance of Dr. Ramasubramanian to make a presentation in
the Planetarium demonstrating the inscriptions on the skies
around circa 3000 BCE.
We have the textual references from the
critical edition of the Mahabharata (Bhandarkar Oriental
Research Institute).
Reading selected inscriptions on the sky
We have the selected inscriptions on the sky
as demonstrated by Prof. Srinivasa Raghavan (using Vedanga
Jyotisha computations).
We have Dr. Narahari Achar's demonstration
and reading of these inscriptions, using computer simulation of
the planetarium with reference to the dates (tithi, naksatra),
planetary positions, Haleys comet (dhu_ma ketu) and
lunar-solar-lunar solar eclipse sequences occurring in two
paks.a-s (one sequence occurring within 13 tithi-s). For
example, the selected inscriptions relate to: Balaramas start
date of pilgrimage on River Sarasvati and return date; the day
of beginning of the war; the date of injury to Bhishma on the 10th
day of the war; the date of Uttara_yan.a (i.e. Bhishmashtami on
ma_gha sukla which occurs after 58 days from the date of injury
since Bhishma waits for the winter solstice to arrive); the
planetary positions during the war as reported by Karna to
Krishna; the occurrences of lunar-solar-lunar eclipse sequences;
and the passing of the Haleys comet on the skies.
Simulating the sky as seen by Veda Vya_sa
(from Kurukshetra, on the banks of River Sarasvati)
A further demonstration of the planetarium
with reference to these selected inscriptions on the sky can be
made by using the Birla Planetarium facilities and the guidance
of astronomers in the Planetarium and Dr. Ramasubramanian.
The idea is to display the texts in Sanskrit
with translations which describe the events on the sky.
This display will be done together with the
demonstration of actual positions of the planets, Haleys comet,
lunar-solar eclipses and the corresponding dates of the
Gregorian calendar and Kaliyuga_bda.
We have a general idea of the advances made
in computational software to go beyond 5000 years Before Present
and also the limitations which have to be overcome to achieve
greater reliability in computations by providing corrections,
for example, for manda-gati ans si_ghra-gati of some planets
and nakshatras.
Once the Birla Planetarium, Chennai, comes up
with this programme, it can be replicated in planetaria all over
the world demonstrating the historicity of the Mahabharata and
the use of the sky inscriptions for treating this text as the
sheet-anchor of the modern history of Bharat.
25 November 2002
S. Kalyanaraman
SARASVATI NADI SHODH PRAKALP
AKHIL BHARATIYA ITIHAASA SANKALANA YOJANA
26/3 Vishali, Temple Avenue, Srinagar Colony,
Saidapet, Chennai 600015
Tel. 2350557; Fax. 4996380 kalyan97@yahoo.com
The links:
A Mahabharata Planetarium Project has been proposed by Dr. S.
Kalyanaraman.
International
Colloquium on the date of the
Kurukshetra
War, based on astronomical data
- held in Bangalore on 5 and 6 January 2003,
- organized by Mythic Society, Indira Gandhi National
Centre for Arts and Babasaheb Apte Smaraka Samiti Trust,
Akhila Bharatiya Itihasa Sankalana Yojana.
Over 200 scholars and scientists participated in the
deliberations which included presentation of well-documented and
well-researched papers/power-point presentations with sky maps,
by scholars from Bharat and from USA.
Background and Executive Summary
The colloquium was made possible by the critical edition of
the text of the Mahabharata compiled by scholars of the
Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute headed by the late Dr.
Sukthankar.
Dr. Raja Ramanna, noted nuclear scientists inaugurated the
colloquium. The colloquium included lectures on many facets of
the use of jyotisha and bharatiya scientific tradition by Dr. KP
Pandurangi, Dr. Suryanath Kamath, Prof. MKLN Shastri, Dr. SR
Rao, Dr. BV Subbarayappa, Dr. A. Sundara, Dr. Nagaraju, Dr. M.A.
Narasimhan, Dr. K.I. Vasu, Dr. Ramasubramanian.
The consensus reached in the colloquium was that there were
over 150 astronomical references in the critical edition which
could be classified by types of celestial events observed and
recorded. The sky inscriptions or celestial epigraphs included:
- planetary/constellation positions on dates of specific
events related to the war and
- starting nakshatra and ending nakshatra of the
pilgrimage of Balarama along the River Sarasvati (described
in the shalya parva),
- the injury to Bhishma and his passing away on the winter
solstice day on shukla ashtami tithi in Rohini,
- position of S'ani in Rohini,
- occurrence of a solar eclipse on jyeshtha and an eclipse
season of three eclipses in one month with a solar eclipse
occurring between two lunar eclipses and the latter sequence
of solar eclipse-penumbral lunar eclipse occurring within 13
tithis (a rare celestial event indeed),
- recorded events of meteor showers and
- occurrence of comets (possibly including the Haley's
comet mahaaghoraa) during the war which lasted 18 days.
Mahabharata is a historical document
It was also noted that the celestial inscriptions or sky
epigraphs were observed events, observed by Veda Vyasa from the
banks of River Sarasvati in the Kurukshetra region. This has
been validated by the references to the mighty river in the
Mahabharata. Recent scientific researches have established
that the River Sarasvati of Vedic times and of the days of the
epic was not a myth but a geo-physical reality as mentioned in
the texts and has been established as ground-truth. [
http://www.hindunet.org/saraswati ] Thus, the Mahabharata
constitutes a historical document with a wealth of geographical,
geophysical information and vivid pictures of the society and
political institutions of the times (such as janapadas involved
in nation-building), in continuation of the Vedic traditions
which refer to Bha_ratam Janam. The consensus was that the
determination of the dates of the war should be based on
establishing the consistency of ALL the astronomical references
contained in the text to make it a useful reference date for
chronologies in ancient bharatiya itihaasa.
Mahabharata is sheet anchor of modern Itihaasa
Against this backdrop of consensus, scholars reached further
consensus that the Mahabharata was a sheet anchor of the
modern history of Bharat. Areas for further were identified as:
- the concept of yuga and mahayuga
- knowledge of comets among ancient Bharatiya scientists
- the need for compiling a critical edition of the
Mahabharata astronomical references based on all variant
readings and excluded verses listed as annexes in the
Critical Edition and including the commentaries of Vadiraja
and Nilakhantha and Madhvacharya's Mahabharata Tatparya
Nirnaya
- further investigation of the reference to the occurrence
of the war during night also on the 14th day of the war
- compilation and research on astronomical references in
the Vedas, Puranas and other astronomical texts.
Thus, the use of modern tools of planetaria software and
satellite image analyses will help in re-writing of bharatiya
itihaasa and reinforce the
historicity of the great epics as basic reference documents
for itihaasa, in terms of both kaalaganana and geography.
A Mahabharata Planetarium Project has been proposed by Dr. S.
Kalyanaraman.
Participants of the Colloquium and their
papers/presentations:
Dr. S. Balakrishna (NASA, USA)
Two eclipses in thirteen days prior to Mahabharatha War
Prof. B.N. Narahari Achar (Dept. of Physics, University of
Memphis, USA)
The Date of Mahabharatha War based on simulation using
Planetarium Software
Dr. S. Kalyanaraman (Sarasvati Nadi Shodh Prakalp, Chennai)
Date of Mahabharatha War with reference to Bhishmashtami
Sri K.V. Ramakrishna Rao (Chennai)
The Date of Mahabharatha based on Indian Astronomical Works
Dr. S. R. Rao (Bangalore)
Archaeological Evidence for Dating Kurukshetra War
Dr. Shambhu Shastry (Franklin, USA) and Dr. Venkateswar Reddy
(Sunnyvale, USA)
Natural Cycles in the Solar System and the Chaturyuga Cycles
The digital versions of the following
papers will be added as and when they become available:
Prof. Mohan Gupt (Ujjain University)
The Date of Mahabharatha War: Puranic and Astronomical
Evidence
"To conclude, 17th of October 1952 BCE, Thursday, Marga
Krishna Amavasya, Kali 1151 of Shaka-purva (Before Shaka)
2029, JUlian year 2762 is the date when Mahabharata War
began. In my detailed treatise on the subject, I have
successfully refuted all theories which fix this date as
3138 BCE or 2448 BCE or 1400 BCE or 3102 BCE. Neither the
planetary position as mentioned in Mahabharata nor the
phenomenon of Uttaryana on the date of passing away of
Mahatma Bhishma do obtain, on respective days in these
dates."
Sri P.V. Holay (Advocate and Astronomer, Nagpur)
Year of Kaurava Pandava War
Abstract
About hundred and twenty scholars have made efforts to
find out the year of Kaurav-Pandava War (which is known as
the Great Bharata War) yet the date has remained uncertain
so far. Its farthest limit is found to be 5561 BCE by Dr.
Vartak and the nearest limit is 1000 BCE by Dr. BB Lal. The
author of this paper found out the date of the war after
keeping in mind all these works.
Some scholars have said that in no case the date of
Bharata war can be earlier than 2000 BCE when we consider
that Bhishmacharya expired in Shukla Paksha of the month of
Magha on the day of Uttarayanaarambha (Winter solstice).
However in those days lunar months were not named in the
manner as we name them to-day according to Jyotisha
Siddhanta System. The author of this paper therefore gave
importance to:
(i) The event that Bhishmacharya expired on Rohini
Nakshatra, the eighth day of shukla paksha, on the day of
winter solstice.According to mathematical calculations the
year is found to be 3341+ - 240 BCE. (ii) as also to the
fact that an intercalary month followed the Kartik month
before the war (iii) the description of the planetary
positions, meteor-showers, diffused atmosphere, reduction in
gravitational force which are narrated in chapter III of
Bhishma Parva is totally scienfe fiction, making us believe
that in those days some comet-like shoemaker moved around
the earth and bursted. The author has therfore totally
ignored the contents of the said chapter. The planetary
positions given in the preceding and succeeding that chapter
form sufficient data for fixing the date of the war (iv)
according to the description in verse 3 of chapter XVIII of
Bhishma parva ten days before the beginning of the war and
according to the contents of verse 4 of chapter XXXVIII
Karna Parva (nis'caranto vyadr.s'yanta su_rya_t sapta maha_
graha_h) on the day of Karna's death; people saw seven
planets in the sky excluding the sun. It was therefore
necessary to search the seventh planet. The seventh planet
is obviously 'Uranus'. The magnitude of Uranus is 5.6. It
can be seen without the aid of the telescope. The vedic
priests must have definitely observed it because they used
to worship Nakshatra deities daily, they, therefore observed
all planets and stars on the ecliptic daily. The author
therefore gave six positions of planets during the period of
the war with sky maps (v) Dr. D. Abhyankar and Dr. Ballabh
of Osmania University have found in 1991 AD the day of
beginning Kaliyuga as 7th February 3104 BCE. THe author of
the paper finds that the war begain 38.3 years before the
said date. That is on 13th Nov. in 2000 AD both these
scholars have given three more probable dates of beginning
of kaliyuga. The relevance of these dates with the date of
Bharata War is discussed.
Dr. N.S. Rajaram (Bangalore)
Mahabharatha Date: A word of caution
We may now summarize the information provided by the
Mahabharata verses as follows:
- The 'Magnificent Bull' (uttama vrsabha) and its
identification with dharma existed in Kasyapa
Prajapati's Nighantuka-Padkhyana. This fact, as well as
the fact that Yaska used it as the source for his own
Nirukta was known to the author of the passage in the
Mahabharata. This image of the Magnificent Bull as
the embodiment of dharma was equated with Krishna-Vishnu
by the time the Shanti Parva of the Mahabharata
came to be written. This suggests that the passage in
the Shanti Parva was composed when Krishna had gained
recognition as an incarnation of Vishnu. The seal
messages found so far suggest that this was already
happening in the Harappan era but received its full
dimension in the post-Harappan period.
- One-horned creatures and three-headed kakudman bulls
appear in great profusion on the Indus seals, especially
the former. In some seal-pictures with three faces one
can also see the birth of bulls with three posteriors.
This again tallies with the description given in the
Mahabharata. (This explains the symbolism of such
creatures: they represent the adi-varaha and not the
'Three-faced Agni' as, at least one prominent scholar
has asserted).
- The famous 'Unicorn Bull' found on a very large
number of the seals is a representation of the same
varaha -- an extremely important symbol for rescuing the
earth from deluge and also for rescuing the Vedas from
oblivion. The varaha, which is rich in Vedic symbolism,
and later plays so important role in th Puranas, was the
royal emblem of many great Hindu rulers and dynasties
like Vikramaditya of Ujjain, the Calukyas, and even
Vijayanagara. It was seen as the emodiment of Vedic
knowledge itself though its symbolism is still not fully
understood. (Its composite bull form suggests that it
represented dharma also).
- Vr.sa and Vr.sa_kapi images as interpreted on the
seals are representations of Dharma. This concept of
associating animals with human as well as deities
prevails to this day among the Hindus. It goes back to
the Rigveda itself. But by the time these descriptions
made their way into the didactic portions of the
Mahabharata the Puranic concepts were already in
vogue. This is clear from references to the Varaha as
saving the Vedas found in the same passage.
We may, therefore, say that the account given in the
Mahabharata represents a transition stage from the Vedic to
Puranic, or perhaps a blending of the two as part of the same
movement that took the Vedic teachings to the common people via
popular works like the Bhagavata. This shows also that
the Mahabharata underwent a long period of evolution --
not of centuries but a thousand years or more -- from the early
Harappan period to the centuries after the Harappan sites had
been abandoned. The question to be faces is -- did the language
of the Mahabharata also undergo changes? Did it evolve
from the spoken Vedic dialects of the kind we find in the early
Upanishads to the epic style pioneered by Valmiki the Adikavi --
the First of Poets? This is a question for future research.
As a result, any astronomical reference in the epic should
take into account both this literary evolution and the
possibility of interpolated passages containing spurious data.
Prof. R.N. Iyengar (IISc, Bangalore)
Internal Consistency of Eclipses and Planetary
Positions in Mahabharata
Abstract
The ancient intellectual tradition of India holds that
the epic Mahabharata reports part of national
history. However, historicity of key personalities like
Krishna has depended more on an unbroken tradition, rather
than on archaeological evidences. The single most important
physical source available for present day study is the text
of Mahabharata itself. It is unlikely that later
reciters and copyists of the epic would have tampered with
descriptions of natural phenomena like eclipses, even though
transmission errors cannot be ruled out. Hence, such
celestial observations would become the most important
physical evidences if they can be scientifically
investigaged and dated. Planetarium softwares are powerful
tools for computer-based searching of thousands of
possibilities and for sifting through obscure texts on
celestial events. Such an exercise in archaeo-astronomy
leads us to the conclusion that the eclipses and planetary
observations of Mahabharata should belong to the
period 1493 BCE - 1443 BCE of Indian history.
Sri R.Y. Sane (Nagpur)
The probable Date of Mahabharatiya War
Shri MV Subbarao (Hyderabad)
Astronomical references and key events of the war
The
Date of Mahabharata
Based
on the Indian
Astronomical
Works
K.V. Ramakrishna Rao, B.Sc., M.A., A.M.I.E., C.Eng.(I)., B.L.,
Introduction:
The date of
Mahabharat is analyzed for determination only based on the
Indian astronomical works. The following facts are taken into
consideration for such critical study:
The Indian
astronomers of Siddhantic works and followers have recorded the
date of Bharata implying Mahabharat war in
particular and starting of Kaliyuga or Era, that
is used to reckon the dates of themselves at many places and in
conjunction with Saka era in some places later.
Aryabhata
makes a specific mention about Bharata in his
Aryabhatiyam. Most of the scholars including westerners have
taken the connotation of it as referring to Mahabharat and in
particular Mahabharat war, because, that is considered as the
staring point of Kaliyuga / era in Indian astronomy and history
too.
Therefore,
taking the astronomical works - Siddhantas, Tantras and Karanas
like - Aryabhatiyam, Mahabhaskariyam, Vatesvara -
Siddhanta and Gola, Sisyadhivrddhida
Tantra and the commentaries thereof, the significance of
such references are studied to find out the date of Mahabharata,
only based on these ancient Indian astronomical works.
As the
authors and commentators have been astronomers, their
authenticity about the astronomical data and information are
reliable and taken for interpretation. Moreover, if the
chronology of any ancient dynasty is taken for study, one can
find that its origin goes back to Mahabharat1
and even beyond. It is not a myth or fantasy2,
but an historical fact that has not been accepted by the
historians on the plea that there are no archaeological
evidences.
Aryabhatas Reference about "Bharata": According to scholars, it is Aryabhata (b.426 CE) who for
the first time mentions about Bharata in his work while giving
the number of years elapsed since the starting of the present
kalpa. He uses the specific expression bharatat purvam,
thus the commentators since his times to present day have been
stimulated with inquisition and thus have analyzed, studied and
interpreted critically.
The verse
goes (Aryabhatiyam.I.5) like this:
Kaho manvo da, manuyugaha: skha, gataste ca, manuyugaha: chuna ca|
Kalpadheryugapadha ga ca, gurudhivasacca, bharatat purvam||
The word
bharata could denote one of the following:
|
|